« Augmented Reality and the Future of Learning & Work | Main | Borrowing from the Library to Support Workplace Learning »

September 28, 2009

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451fd2469e20120a5fc9a0b970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference It's Not the Tool That's Boring. It's You.:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I'm partially/largely with you on this.... but not totally.

Thing is, while you're right, some tools are just hard work to be interesting with and others are easier. Sure, people should design better powerpoint slides but it's an effort because PPT is designed badly... for example the default font is just plan inappropriate and the default template is boring.

Sure you *can* change it, but.....

Don't get me wrong, I use powerpoint (I even train people in using it - but let's not forget that there are better alternatives out there).

Cheers.... Simon

Simon, I agree 100% that the design of a tool can make it more or less interesting as a designer to work with. If it's clunky and difficult to use, then we're less likely to be engaged with it and want to use it for teaching. So if we want to complain that a tool lacks the right features and functionality for the kinds of learning we want to support, I get that. But when people say that the tool is "boring," I don't think that they're talking about the functionality as much as the content. In Sarah's example, the complaints were about VLEs being boring, but upon further probing, it was clear that they were boring because they weren't being used properly. What was boring was their content (PPT slides and little else), which is a failure of design on the part of teachers, not a failure on the part of the VLE. Not that I'm a big fan of a VLE--I think PLEs are more where we need to be. Still, I think that most of the time when people say a learning activity is boring, they are talking about the content and learning process, not the actual tool.

Great point - one that is LARGELY ignored and taken for granted.

But it is easier to be boring. This goes along with my 'mediocrity' rant. It is 'good enough' and everyone expects it but complains about it, but, because it is good enough, they tolerate it.

Yet those moments of learning come when we get out of that rut.

Thanks for bringing Sarah's post to my attention. I agree with you about the tools and their use. I think it's a shame when the baby is thrown out with the bath water. For example, 'traditional' Teachmeets do not allow the use of PowerPOint, in order to avert Death by PowerPoint. That, IMHO, is a mistake, because it doesn't address the real issues.

I062RL I want to say - thank you for this!

Kia ora e Michele!

Well I agree with you, for the way the technology is used is where it's at, not the technology.

An old saying, "A poor craftsman blames his tools", reflects that idea. So nothing new here except, perhaps, the technology, and PP's not that new either.

I use PP for presentations, but the rules I use are:

1 Never look at the screen when addressing the learners.
2 Never read the text that the learners are trying to read for themselves.
3 Never dump the PP in the VLE on its own.

This last point shows how a trainer can abdicate his or her responsibility for follow up.

One technique I use is to edit my notes, quickly culling all that I covered, leaving all that I didn't manage to cover or had decided to leave out - for whatever reason. This may also include vids and possibly even PP slides I decided not to view during a session.

It doesn't take long to tidy this all up, and makes for a useful follow-up to drop into the VLE after the presentation. Feedback should be solicited immediately after the session, and this can give a better idea of what you might include in follow up material put in the VLE.

This is not only good practice, it is also good pedagogy.

Catchya later

I agree with Ken Allan. What bugs me the most about people presenting with ppt is that they will simply spend the majority of the time looking at and reading off the screen. What a great stimulating post.

Hey Michelle,
Great post! As always.

I really agree with your assessment of both PPT and VLEs and that you can't blame the tool for a lack of creativity. It really bugs me when people just assume that PPT is a dumping ground for bullet points. One piece of advice I follow (which I think I got from Tom Kuhlmann) is to start a PPT presentation with the blank template and avoid the bullet ones. I don't know what Microsoft was thinking when they made more than half of their templates include bullet points. In that way, the tool guides us to think in text instead of pictures.

Many of the presentations I get from my clients are just slide after slide of bullet points. So, I study the content and determine how to depict the key points more visually. The visuals are much more effective than the bullet points because they show relationships that the bullets hide.

Totally agree, Michelle.
I'm trying to remember that last time I heard someone blame a boring book on the quality of the printing press.
The quality of content has nothing to do with the technology used to create and publish it. (Not that quality tools aren't important too!)

I agree, but also think that Technology is naturally seductive to explorers. It's a bit like buying really expensive mountain gear for a simple bushwalk, sometimes the best technology for a task is a simple one. If you want to get a point across, choose the most appropriate tools within your stable.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Get Email Updates on the Blog

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Sign Up for the Email Newsletter

Search This Site

  • Google Custom Search

Get Some Clarity and Inspiration!